ToS;DR

Any content you add to the site is permanently public


Service: Wikipedia
Status: DECLINED
Case: This service holds onto content that you've deleted
Changes: 8
Source: link
Author:


<li>Any content you add or any change that you make to a Wikimedia Site will be publicly and permanently available.</li>
This is a disadvantage and terrible idea for users who added information they did not realize they should not have added to the site. This is especially a detriment for any minors (users under the age of 21) who use the service, whenever they add content which could affect them or hurt them.


Comments:
On 2019-04-01 07:51:59 UTC, (deactivated) wrote:

approved:

On 2019-05-12 12:20:48 UTC, hugo Curator wrote:

changes-requested: I suggest to reframe this.

Wikipedia is a public encyclopedia, so it is normal that content is public and permanent. However, I agree it's a problem that the Privacy Policy does not say anything about how to deal with exceptional cases where people should have a right to have information related to them removed (e.g. a minor).

On 2019-05-31 10:11:27 UTC, wrote:

Re-phrasing

On 2019-05-31 10:19:42 UTC, wrote:

Re-phrasing

On 2019-06-20 08:31:01 UTC, jessew Curator wrote:

approved: without comment

On 2019-07-10 15:53:14 UTC, Tem Corner wrote:

Incorrect - For over a decade there have been ways for individual edits, as well as entire articles, to be deleted. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Revision_deletion and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion

On 2019-08-11 09:08:39 UTC, wrote:

Yes, it's true, but it would be helpful if the privacy policy also explained that to remove information that they can be deleted and/or oversighted. At the moment, right now, even if edits are deleted or oversighted, they remain in the site's database FOR ETERNITY. And edits that are deleted are recoverable by any admin, while edits that are oversighted are recoverable only by a developer. Perhaps the privacy policy itself could mention about removing information by deleting and/or oversighting edits.

On 2020-07-06 19:01:45 UTC, michielbdejong ToS;DR wrote:

declined: We're replacing this point with one that has case https://edit.tosdr.org/cases/394, so that is more balanced.



We track editorial changes to analyses and updates to a point's status and display the previous versions here as part of an effort to promote transparency regarding our curation process.

Version 1: 2020-07-06 19:01:45 UTC by michielbdejong ToS;DR

Previous Title: No changes recorded

Updated Title: No changes recorded

Previous Analysis: No changes recorded

Updated Analysis: No changes recorded

Previous Status: APPROVED

Updated Status: DECLINED

Version 2: 2019-06-20 08:31:00 UTC by jessew Curator

Previous Title: No changes recorded

Updated Title: No changes recorded

Previous Analysis: No changes recorded

Updated Analysis: No changes recorded

Previous Status: PENDING

Updated Status: APPROVED

Version 3: 2019-05-31 10:19:42 UTC by

Previous Title: No changes recorded

Updated Title: No changes recorded

Previous Analysis: This is a disadvantage and terrible idea for users who added information they did not realize they should not have added to the site. This is especially a detriment for any minors (users under the age of 21) who use the service, whenever they add content which could affect them or harm them.

Updated Analysis: This is a disadvantage and terrible idea for users who added information they did not realize they should not have added to the site. This is especially a detriment for any minors (users under the age of 21) who use the service, whenever they add content which could affect them or hurt them.

Previous Status: No changes recorded

Updated Status: No changes recorded

Version 4: 2019-05-31 10:11:27 UTC by

Previous Title: No changes recorded

Updated Title: No changes recorded

Previous Analysis: This is a disadvantage and terrible idea for users who added information they did not realize they should not have added to the site. This is especially a detriment for any minors (users under the age of 21) who use the service, adding content which would have a serious impact on their life, content they added which would hurt them later on.

Updated Analysis: This is a disadvantage and terrible idea for users who added information they did not realize they should not have added to the site. This is especially a detriment for any minors (users under the age of 21) who use the service, whenever they add content which could affect them or harm them.

Previous Status: CHANGES REQUESTED

Updated Status: PENDING

Version 5: 2019-05-12 12:20:48 UTC by hugo Curator

Previous Title: No changes recorded

Updated Title: No changes recorded

Previous Analysis: No changes recorded

Updated Analysis: No changes recorded

Previous Status: APPROVED

Updated Status: CHANGES REQUESTED

Version 6: 2019-04-01 07:51:59 UTC by ps Curator

Previous Title: No changes recorded

Updated Title: No changes recorded

Previous Analysis: No changes recorded

Updated Analysis: No changes recorded

Previous Status: PENDING

Updated Status: APPROVED

Version 7: 2019-03-31 03:50:03 UTC by

Previous Title: No changes recorded

Updated Title: No changes recorded

Previous Analysis: No changes recorded

Updated Analysis: No changes recorded

Previous Status: No changes recorded

Updated Status: No changes recorded

Version 8: 2019-03-31 03:48:01 UTC by

Previous Title:

Updated Title: Any content you add to the site is permanently public

Previous Analysis:

Updated Analysis: This is a disadvantage and terrible idea for users who added information they did not realize they should not have added to the site. This is especially a detriment for any minors (users under the age of 21) who use the service, adding content which would have a serious impact on their life, content they added which would hurt them later on.

Previous Status:

Updated Status: PENDING